Grading Your Morning Show, Giving It All C’s
I’ve spoken before in Planet Reynolds about the foundational elements every show needs to be strategic: what is the show about (its “plot”)? What is your game plan for character development? Is the cast focused on earning the right images to drive loyalty? Does the show have significant benchmark appointments, that cannot be duplicated, which will drive occasions back to the program?
I talk with new shows about the “need for C’s”. A subjective metric to assess if your show is on course. These are the Four C’s every talent and show should work on, around the framework above, to assure they’re strategic. How would you rate your show in each of these areas?
- Connection. Despite social media, the internet, and all that texting, human beings, at their core, desire connection. Human to human contact is essential to developing a relationship. I recently joined Clear so I can get through security lines faster at airports. From registering to finishing my account at their kiosk to the security line, I was accompanied by an actual human being. Ever call a customer service number, only to sit through three minutes of pressing “1” for this and “2” for that before you get a person who can help? I bet you’re not happier after all of that. Connection is one of radio’s superpowers. The audience wants to connect with your talent, and they must work on that purposefully when doing the show.
- Companionship. We learned during Covid, with everyone sequestered in their homes with their small circle of family for over one year, that companionship is critical. Companionship fosters a deep relationship. Think of those in your personal life you’re close to. They provide you companionship. Deep inside, so many listeners feel alone. Scrolling Facebook a million times a day doesn’t fix that. We can, though, by reminding the audience that, wherever they are in life, they aren’t alone if they hang out with us.
- Content. This is how we accomplish numbers one and two above. We engage with certain websites because we’re looking for content. We turn on a TV show because we want content. Pop open Facebook, Instagram or any other social media app? You’re looking for content. Same for your audience. They’re looking for content, too. Are you on the best content in each break on every day? Or is it irrelevant pablum the audience shrugs their shoulders at? The right content affords connection and companionship.
- Comedy. Life sucks, so make people laugh. In the two decades I’ve coached shows in North America and Europe, there is one constant: no show wins without solid humor images. Not laugh in a set up/punchline kind of way. Not in doing wacky “radio bits”. Listeners want to be around genuine, fun people. Yea, there are days the news or pop culture cycle compels us to be serious – those are outliers, and we must respect them – but go have fun and people will wanna be around you.
The Four C’s: Connection, Companionship, Content, and Comedy.
It might be instructional to ask your show to grade themselves in each area on a 1-10 scale, with managers doing it, too. Compare those grades and see where you match. Any disparity gives great programmers an opportunity to influence their show with yet another strategic conversation about their growth.
I’d be interested to hear how that turns out so let me know.
Because grading your morning show and giving them all C’s might just keep you on the path to being f’n epic.

Years ago, one month out of the first anniversary of the Boston bombings, I decided to engage the two shows I work with in that city around what our programs will sound like that day. I received back, as is sometimes the case, silence. When I was on the air, I was the king of never planning. I usually worried about large milestone shows like this the day before. We don’t have that luxury any longer because of the competition for listeners’ attention.
My friend Bruce St. James, who does mornings at WLS, Chicago, is incredibly smart (a good talent trait), but also quite curious (that’s what makes him smart!). I happened upon this tweet the day the Cosby story broke, which said it all. Bruce was also curious about how Cosby could be let out, so that fueled his breaks. And the audience naturally took the trip with him.
There’s a show out west I don’t know but like as a listener. I’ve never met the people doing the program. As fate would have it, the anchor pinged me on Facebook wanting to set up a Zoom to say hello.
Do your talent have EPIC in them? Are they high performers, always seeking that next level, welcoming the challenge for growth? Are they confident to not be the smartest, bestest, funniest, or most strategic in the room?
Spend time as I have over these many years coaching and observing great talent and you’ll start seeing why they excel.
Once done at Staples, I’ll probably head to Krispy Kreme, show my laminated vaccination card, and get my free donut. Who goes to Krispy Kreme for one donut? Anyone with even a marginal pulse buys a dozen. Sold! They did the same thing – put themselves in the story to create talk. Every radio show I listened to told me that, too.
I work with Sander Hoogendoorn, the morning guy on 3FM in the Netherlands. I love Sander. He’s very creative and brought to one of our Skypes the idea on the right. Unless you know Dutch, that long hashtag in the picture says #showyourshot. Once listeners get their vaccine, we’ll give them one of those bandages on his arm and ask them to send us a picture of themselves showing us their shot. It’s our way of inserting ourselves into the story to create buzz through images which will all be placed on our social media channels to positively influence people to get their vaccines. They’ll talk about us!
Michael Strahan removed the gap between his front teeth, and I can’t figure out why. It’s one of the distinguishing physical characteristics of the NFL on Sunday and Good Morning America host.
Ries and Trout talk about points-of-parity and points-of-differentiation in their iconic book, The 22 Immutable Laws of Marketing. They ask the question, and I, in turn, ask every personality I work with: what is noticeably different about what we do that helps us stand out?