The Greatest Story Never Told
A few weeks ago, when the Titan submarine story was all over the news, I got a late-night text from an anchor of a show I work with.
The show had befriended a local professor a year earlier who’d gone into space. Intrigued by the story, they talked with him on the program and found out he liked adventurous experiences which he brought into his classroom for discussion with students. They were going to do another break on the lost submarine and the anchor texted the professor to see if he’d ever been in a sub, wondering if he could offer something into the discussion no one on the show could.
The professor asked the talent to call him immediately. The professor shared that he was due to be on the actual Titan voyage that went missing and proved it by sending a picture of the sub on a boat ready to launch at the dock without him. He was uncomfortable with the language in the agreement and his instincts told him to bail from the trip.
If you’re thinking “wow” right now and getting chills, you’re not alone.
He wouldn’t come on the show because he knew it had blown up and everyone had perished, but that news hadn’t been released to America yet and he wanted to be respectful.
Why am I sharing this story? Because I want you to see how this show preps its daily content. Instead of a generic survey or bland phone topic, this show was so deeply curious about the biggest topic of the moment that they tried to figure out how to become the rabbit hole for listeners. Their efforts were to create a break around the topic no one else could.
If you’re a manager, listen to your entire morning show tomorrow and rate it against the funny graphic my friend Kris Rochester did to the left. Where does your show fall on every break on the Steve Reynolds Content Tracker 3000? Is your show doing birthdays, this date in history, surveys and lists or some other equally bland and generic content? Or are you on top shelf content that makes you relevant?
More specifically, how hard are you prepping to be about the moment? About what’s going on right now? And not in a way that only shares the information or story readily available to everyone in every place they look. How relevant are you? Relevance is an image that keeps fans returning to the show.
Despite the professor not coming on that show (yet), our team there is always thinking: what is the conversation the audience is having right now and how do we join it in a way no one else can? This show does that around every hot topic (nationally and locally) which makes me immensely proud and a reason they’re pulling a 16-share A25-54.
Take a random hour of your show tomorrow and re-air it in three weeks. On the re-air, listen to hear if the content feels stale. If it does, then it really worked on the day it was originally offered.
Being epic is about being in the moment. Is the content you’re hearing bland, boring, generic, or evergreen? Or is your show about today’s topics, being done in a way that reflects the curiosity of your personalities so you continue to build a unique product that can’t be duplicated across the street?

We can talk in another Planet Reynolds about the constant re-branding by HBO. I’d always thought that the value of HBO’s programming over the years was in those three letters H-B-and-O and am not really sure what “Max” means. But that’s for another time. What I’m reminded is that change is fraught with peril. Which is why I sighed again getting an email from them, suggesting I “find my way around the app to find everything.” I have no time to learn a new app. They’re making me work for it. And no one likes that.
I am looking at new cars. The biggest downside in my decision? I’ll need to learn where all the buttons are to do everything again. It’ll be frustrating and is a vote to not do it because it’s taxiing and unnerving. Change rattles us. Which is why we keep gravitating back to what we know, even if it ain’t the best. I know where to find my content on the (now defunct) HBO Max app. I don’t on their new one. Why did they make that change and why is it on me to learn it?
We all know there isn’t a direct line from the radio you do to the growth in the ratings. There are tons of variables, some out of your control. Some shows I’ve worked with took years to break through. Keeping them centered on that journey is job #1.
Welcome back to the grind. I hope your break was relaxing and you had great time off to decompress, recharge, and not think even once about radio. For those of you who keep the early hours (my fellow morning folks), I hope you slept in past 6:00am.
An example. Six years ago, we had this conversation at Indie 88, Toronto. The morning show said that homelessness was their cause. At any given moment in the winter, there are 5000 homeless on the streets of Toronto. The show went to the shelters to talk with the homeless as well as those who’ve dedicated their lives to taking care of them. They heard stories that more deeply impacted the effort. Our show is built around being different. If it smacks of pro forma, we tend to back up and think about it some more. We learned that what homeless people need more than anything else is socks to prevent frostbite.
a wounded warrior who lives in town. Or we camp out at grocery stores, asking listeners to buy us a bag of pet food we give to the shelters so they can save that money in their budgets. We do a similar campaign at KSLX, Phoenix with Mark and NeanderPaul’s Operation Pets and Vets. Focused, big, different.
Case in point is Karson and Kennedy, MIX 104.1, Boston. They were approached by the Marines years ago, asking them to raise toys for their Toys for Tots campaign. We re-framed the effort to Karson and Kennedy’s 10,000 Toys for Girls and Boys. Lots of shows do this now, but we were the first. We made it ours, listeners responded positively, we built our own show’s images, and turned everything over to the Marines. A win all the way around because it fed our cause: kids.
With school back in session and the fall upon us, listeners are back to their post-summer routines. Inspired by the smart brand managers and talent I’ve been around, here are some reminders that will help your show:
Encouraged by their great managers (Brian Maloney and Sammy Simpson), Kyle, Bryan, and Sarah, WRAL-FM, Raleigh, have worked tirelessly to have this kind of relationship with their audience. From an on-air discussion about what happened in Uvalde, they received that unexpected call from a total stranger – a local woman who was in the Columbine school shootings several years prior. She was encouraged by her kid in the back seat to call the show as they were listening to share her experience given the on-air conversation. More humanity and compassion. A story that resonated with the team and proves how comfortable that total stranger was to honor her relationship with those guys by baring her soul.
Many of us read in Malcolm Gladwell’s book, Outliers, that it takes 10,000 hours of intensive practice to achieve mastery of a complex skill.
We’d ask the talent what fixes the larger ratings issues so they could take ownership of the right path forward. And each time we would get back the same answer: we need better prizes.